Is the Tesla Model 3 Our Ride to a Sustainable Future?

Automakers should see this month’s news—and the news yet to come—as a call to action for a bolder transportation vision. Traditional engines are on their way out, but it’s not enough to just replace gas with electric. Eliot Metzger and Alyssa Fischer explain.

Tesla charging in Denmark (Photo by News Oresund, edited, CC BY 2.0)


Last month, Elon Musk shared the first images of a production Tesla Model 3—the much-anticipated new electric vehicle that had hundreds of thousands of people lining up last year to place preorders. It was the latest in a series of major recent announcements about the future of the automotive industry.

In July, Volvo Cars announced all of its new models will be electric or hybrid by 2019. Meanwhile, France announced it intends to end sales of gasoline and diesel cars by 2040, which follows similar goals in Norway (2025) and India (2030). In early August, General Motors grabbed headlines as its Chevy Bolt rolled out nationwide.

All the attention on electric vehicles raises the question: Is this the path to sustainable mobility?

Yes: Electric vehicles can be a cleaner alternative to conventional vehicles.

We are paying a heavy toll for our reliance on conventional vehicles. Health care costs, lost productivity and other consequences of road pollution amounted to $3 trillion in lost GDP collectively among OECD countries, China and India in 2010.

Electric vehicles offer a cleaner alternative, especially as more renewable energy is incorporated into the power grid. A recent study, factoring in emissions from the generation of electricity, shows the average battery electric vehicle in the U.S. today emits 214g of carbon dioxide per mile—far less than the 356g to 409g of carbon dioxide per mile produced by conventional gasoline vehicles.

Yes: A lot of people want to buy them.

What is perhaps most exciting about the Model 3 is the unprecedented demand. Never before has an electric vehicle—or any vehicle—had nearly half-a-million preorders a year before production. Electric cars officially have mass-market appeal. As a result, Bloomberg New Energy Finance is now projecting electric vehicles will account for more than half of new car sales by 2040 as demand increases and battery costs decline.

Electric vehicle market penetration is critical to efforts to address climate change. New electric cars will need to be more attractive, affordable and accessible to consumers who are driving today, as well as billions of people reaching middle income around the world who will be driving tomorrow. To reduce greenhouse gas emissions, electric car sales will need to go from zero to 60 in a hurry. Scenarios from the International Energy Agency suggest that to keep pace with a pathway to limit global warming to 2 degrees C (3.6 degrees F), we need the global stock of electric cars to increase from 1 million in 2015 to more than 20 million in 2020 and more than 150 million in 2030.

No: Electric vehicles are not, by themselves, going to get us to sustainable mobility.

Anyone banking on selling millions more electric vehicles is ignoring the elephant in the room—and the billions of vehicles already on the road. Estimates of the annual cost of congestion in the U.S., for example, exceed $100 billion. If the total number of cars continues to climb at its projected pace, we will not have a chance of limiting global warming, even if many of those cars are electric. Neither will selling cleaner cars solve the challenges of congestion, road safety, equal access to opportunity or other mobility issues. This is why the World Resources Institute and others champion the Avoid-Shift-Improve framework (see below), which emphasizes the types of investments that ultimately will allow people to move around in sustainable ways.

So Which Car Companies Will Embrace New Approaches for Tomorrow’s Markets?

Automakers should see this month’s news—and the news yet to come—as a call to action for a bolder transportation vision. World Resources Institute’s Elephant in the Boardroom paper outlines three ways companies might respond:

1. Some will ignore the signals of market transformation. Investors are already looking to assess the leaders and laggards and better understand who is positioned to win or lose.

2. Some will improve on existing options and make incremental progress.They may sell cleaner, more efficient vehicles, but that by itself is not enough to solve congestion or climate change.

3. Some will embrace new business models and mobility services. We need more companies investing in the systems and services that meet customers’ mobility needs without putting more and more cars on the road. Bill Ford knows this. As he said in 2011:

“For most of [my 30 years at Ford Motor Company], I worried about how am I going to sell more cars and trucks. But today I worry about, what if all we do is sell more cars and trucks? What happens when the number of cars on the road doubles, triples or even quadruples?”

This seems to be part of the reason Ford made a leadership change this year and is making investments in ride sharing and even bike sharing.

All these developments and recent announcements are welcome. But more is needed—quickly. It’s a race worth watching. Who will be the first to grow their business without simply selling more cars to more people?

The Avoid-Shift-Improve (ASI) Framework

The first aspect of sustainable mobility involves investments in options that allow people to avoid unnecessary trips, like walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods and options for telecommuting from home and shared-work spaces. These strategies can also include Transport Demand Management solutions like congestion charging, which can disincentivize people from driving in crowded areas at busy times, thereby reducing unnecessary congestion.

The second aspect encourages investment in infrastructure that allows people to shift to other transport options that are better suited to move people around the cities of tomorrow, like walking, biking and public transit.Research shows that connected cities that have strong public transit systems and safe infrastructure for cycling and walking boost GDP, create new jobs and create considerable cost savings.

Combining solutions from each of these two aspects with the third—improvement of transportation technology like electric vehicles—is the only sure-fire way create safer, cleaner, more convenient, affordable and sustainable transportation. We already know that cities around the world are growing at unprecedented rates and those urban residents are going to have more money to invest in their transportation needs. The ASI Framework can be a guide to disrupting the current transport industry and ensuring that these growing communities reflect our vision of a more sustainable, equitable future.

Companies that want to embrace a new approach for tomorrow’s markets can find ways to advance the ASI Framework and move beyond outdated models of selling more cars to more people.

This article has been republished with permission from the WRI Blog.

Eliot Metzger is a senior associate in the World Resources Institute’s Business Center. Alyssa Fischer is the strategy and management associate for the World Resources Institute Ross Center for Sustainable Cities.

Source: The energiewende blog – German Energy Transition

More trains, planes & automobiles news

Pondering: Progression Of The EV Revolution (2017–2030)

Most of you reading this are in agreement: electric vehicles will upend the conventional vehicle industry within the next 50 10–20 years. The pollution industry in the world of transport will be destroyed. Gasmobiles stinking up cities, garages, lungs, hearts, and minds will be retiring to scrapyards and history books. But the endgame is sort […] read on

Future News — Dateline February 14th, 2030

… With anchor Jane Curtain III. Tonight’s top story… The last automobile powered by an internal combustion engine was sent to the salvage yard today. We will have film at 11:00pm showing a 1959 Cadillac Eldorado convertible being towed into Monster Joe’s Auto & Trucks Dismantlers in Los Angeles, California. The car had been hidden […] read on

The Rise Of The E-Bike: Smart Choice For Commuting & Better Health

The e-bike revolution is gaining ground quickly as more people discover the health and economic benefits of riding a bicycle versus driving, especially in crowded cities. The Rise Of The E-Bike: Smart Choice For Commuting & Better Health was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ | […] read on

Tesla Model 3 & Nissan LEAF 2.0 Reflections — Cleantech Talk Returns! Again!

Hello again, listeners and readers. After a longer than expected off-season, Cleantech Talk is back! Season 3’s contributions should be a bit more regular than Season 2 was, given that I’ve moved — “pivoted” in Silicon Valley lingo — from my full-time engineering job to communications consulting, specifically to be able to dedicate more time […] read on

10 Ways Women Can Beat Back Misogyny In The Tech World: Part 3

In this third and final installment, we examine a series of positive ways that women in tech can rise up against an institutional climate of separation 10 Ways Women Can Beat Back Misogyny In The Tech World: Part 3 was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ […] read on

8:26 Seconds With First Tesla Model 3 Delivered Outside Of California — Austin, Texas

The first Tesla Model 3 delivered outside of California has found its way to Austin, Texas, where the delivery process was videotaped and uploaded to YouTube by Matt Holm, a friend of the proud new owner. 8:26 Seconds With First Tesla Model 3 Delivered Outside Of California — Austin, Texas was originally published on CleanTechnica. […] read on

Baidu Releases Apollo 1.5 (New Open-Source Autonomous Driving Platform) & Announces $1.5 Billion Fund

The China-based tech giant Baidu has released the newest iteration of its widely used open-source autonomous driving platform Apollo — which has been dubbed Apollo 1.5, appropriately enough Baidu Releases Apollo 1.5 (New Open-Source Autonomous Driving Platform) & Announces $1.5 Billion Fund was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 […] read on

32nd Annual International Coastal Cleanup Gets Hundreds Of Thousands Of Volunteers Involved Worldwide

The 32nd annual International Coastal Cleanup took place on September 16 and provided hundreds of thousands of volunteers with an opportunity to help keep plastic trash out of the oceans. 32nd Annual International Coastal Cleanup Gets Hundreds Of Thousands Of Volunteers Involved Worldwide was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over […] read on

Plug-in Hybrid Cars Must Be Plugged In. Who Knew?

A report by Fleet News slams plug-in hybrid cars. But its analysis is twisted to show bias toward diesels. Plug-in Hybrid Cars Must Be Plugged In. Who Knew? was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ | Email | Facebook | RSS | Twitter. read on

Even With Huge Carbon Emissions Reductions World’s Periglacial Zones (Home To Permafrost) To Disappear By 2100, Research Finds

The world’s periglacial zones, home to essentially all of the world’s permafrost, will “almost completely disappear” by the year 2100 even in the most optimistic of scenarios concerning greenhouse gas emissions reductions, according to a new study Even With Huge Carbon Emissions Reductions World’s Periglacial Zones (Home To Permafrost) To Disappear By 2100, Research Finds […] read on

Lithium From A Surprising Source (Infographic)

If we’re going to scale up electric vehicle production, we need an abundance of lithium. Mining or production capacity is quite limited at this point, and it looks like the oil industry might be the best source of this valuable mineral going forward towards a more renewable future Lithium From A Surprising Source (Infographic) was […] read on

Electric Car S-Curve Adoption By Country (Fun Chart!)

Electric car sales are increasing at very different speeds around the world. Some developed countries still only see a handful of electric car sales per month. Others are moving hundreds of cars off of lots and into garages every day Electric Car S-Curve Adoption By Country (Fun Chart!) was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read […] read on

Tesla Exploring Opening Service Stations Alongside Superchargers

Tesla is reportedly exploring the possibility of opening service stations to be co-located with its Superchargers, reports GrubStreet Tesla Exploring Opening Service Stations Alongside Superchargers was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ | Email | Facebook | RSS | Twitter. read on

Tesla Reportedly Working With AMD On Self-Driving AI Chip

Tesla is reportedly now working with the chip manufacturer AMD on the development of its own self-driving tech management AI chip, according to an unnamed source quoted by CNBC in a recent article Tesla Reportedly Working With AMD On Self-Driving AI Chip was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 […] read on

Plug-In Electric Vehicle Sales In North America To Be 50% Higher In 2017 Than In 2016, Navigant Research Report States

Sales of plug-in electric vehicles in the North American markets will be roughly 50% higher in 2017 than they were were in 2016, based on current trends, according to a new report from Navigant Research. That should come as no surprise to those of you who follow our monthly electric car sales reports Plug-In Electric […] read on

“Tesla Supercharger” For Your Phone … As You Wait For Your Model 3

Tesla Model 3 reservation holders that are getting a bit impatient, and desperate for any sort of distraction at all, may be interested in reading about their ability to purchase (or 3D print) their own Tesla Supercharger–styled smartphone charger “Tesla Supercharger” For Your Phone … As You Wait For Your Model 3 was originally published […] read on

Uber only has itself to blame for London license loss

 The tech industry’s over-processed supply of irony might not be enough to service all the ramifications of Uber being stripped of its London license by the city’s transport regulator. Read More read on

10 Ways Women Can Beat Back Misogyny In The Tech World: Part 2

In this second part of our three-part series, we explore ways that women in tech can have long and successful careers through deliberative decision-making 10 Ways Women Can Beat Back Misogyny In The Tech World: Part 2 was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ | Email […] read on

First Responder Manual Offers A Glimpse Into How The Tesla Model 3 Is Made

The manual for first responders offers a glimpse into how the Tesla Model 3 is built. First Responder Manual Offers A Glimpse Into How The Tesla Model 3 Is Made was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over 50,000 other subscribers: Google+ | Email | Facebook | RSS | Twitter. read on

Lux Research: Innovation Interest In Renewables Is Declining, Peak Occurred 4 Years Ago

Innovation interest in renewable energy tech has been declining in recent years, achieving a peak around 4 years ago, according to a recent analysis from Lux Research. According to the market research firm, this means that the long-term growth trajectory of the market is “thrown into question” — further “innovation momentum” is necessary for continued […] read on

BorgWarner To Supply Unnamed EV Auto Manufacturer With PTC Cabin Heating Tech, To Improve Range

BorgWarner will be providing an unnamed but globally active electric vehicle auto manufacturer with its new high-voltage positive temperature coefficient cabin heating tech — for use in a new electric vehicle offering — according to a new press release BorgWarner To Supply Unnamed EV Auto Manufacturer With PTC Cabin Heating Tech, To Improve Range was […] read on

Biodegradable Material Could Replace Most Plastic Used To Wrap & Preserve Food

Researchers at Penn State have developed new biodegradable compostable coatings that could lower the amount of plastic needed to package and ship food, helping keep more plastic from clogging landfills and ruining the oceans. Biodegradable Material Could Replace Most Plastic Used To Wrap & Preserve Food was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from […] read on

Air Pollution Exposure & Kidney Disease Linked By New Study

Exposure to air pollution increases the risk of experiencing a decline in kidney function and developing kidney disease, according to a new study published in the Journal of the American Society of Nephrology Air Pollution Exposure & Kidney Disease Linked By New Study was originally published on CleanTechnica. To read more from CleanTechnica, join over […] read on

XOM
79.92
+0.03
+0.04%
GE
24.87
+0.12
+0.48%
CVX
117.29
+0.82
+0.70%
PTR
62.81
-0.51
-0.81%
TOT
54.02
+0.11
+0.20%
BP
37.82
+0.12
+0.32%
SLB
68.8
+0.71
+1.04%
SNP
75.69
-0.45
-0.59%
BBL
36.36
-0.03
-0.08%
E
32.98
+0.05
+0.15%
OXY
62.94
+0.19
+0.30%
COP
49.08
+0.39
+0.80%
STO
20
+0.14
+0.70%
PSX
89.89
+0.75
+0.84%
SU
34.12
-0.09
-0.26%
EOG
94.55
+0.66
+0.70%
PBR
10.34
+0.06
+0.58%
EMR
63.44
0.00
0.00%
ENB
41.04
-0.4
-0.97%
HAL
44.25
+0.77
+1.77%
VLO
74.29
+0.93
+1.27%
CNQ
34.09
-0.11
-0.32%
IMO
31.64
+0.01
+0.03%
PHG
41.74
-0.12
-0.29%
APC
48.83
+0.34
+0.70%
PXD
144.01
+2
+1.41%
BHI
57.68
+3.17
+5.82%
MPC
54.73
+0.36
+0.66%
SSL
28.36
+0.04
+0.14%
CMI
167.98
+1.5
+0.90%
APA
43.57
+0.21
+0.48%
HES
44.5
+0.87
+1.99%
MMP
70.27
-0.03
-0.04%
NBL
27.02
+0.07
+0.26%
CXO
127.06
+0.76
+0.60%
CAM
66.01
-1.04
-1.55%
DVN
35.78
+0.43
+1.22%
NOV
35.54
+0.34
+0.97%
CLR
37.82
+0.16
+0.42%
CVE
10.28
+0.18
+1.78%
TSO
99.53
+1.66
+1.70%
PBA
34.13
-0.43
-1.25%
EQT
64.26
+0.42
+0.66%
PAA
21.58
-0.14
-0.64%
XEC
110.85
+1.48
+1.35%
COG
26.58
+0.17
+0.64%
BPL
55.8
-0.16
-0.29%
MPLX
34.19
+0.17
+0.50%
IEP
54.72
+0.54
+0.9967%
MRO
12.79
+0.06
+0.47%
XOM
79.92
+0.03
+0.04%
GE
24.87
+0.12
+0.48%
CVX
117.29
+0.82
+0.70%
PTR
62.81
-0.51
-0.81%
TOT
54.02
+0.11
+0.20%
BP
37.82
+0.12
+0.32%
SLB
68.8
+0.71
+1.04%
SNP
75.69
-0.45
-0.59%
BBL
36.36
-0.03
-0.08%
E
32.98
+0.05
+0.15%
OXY
62.94
+0.19
+0.30%
COP
49.08
+0.39
+0.80%
STO
20
+0.14
+0.70%
PSX
89.89
+0.75
+0.84%
SU
34.12
-0.09
-0.26%
EOG
94.55
+0.66
+0.70%
PBR
10.34
+0.06
+0.58%
EMR
63.44
0.00
0.00%
ENB
41.04
-0.4
-0.97%
HAL
44.25
+0.77
+1.77%
VLO
74.29
+0.93
+1.27%
CNQ
34.09
-0.11
-0.32%
IMO
31.64
+0.01
+0.03%
PHG
41.74
-0.12
-0.29%
APC
48.83
+0.34
+0.70%
PXD
144.01
+2
+1.41%
BHI
57.68
+3.17
+5.82%
MPC
54.73
+0.36
+0.66%
SSL
28.36
+0.04
+0.14%
CMI
167.98
+1.5
+0.90%
APA
43.57
+0.21
+0.48%
HES
44.5
+0.87
+1.99%
MMP
70.27
-0.03
-0.04%
NBL
27.02
+0.07
+0.26%
CXO
127.06
+0.76
+0.60%
CAM
66.01
-1.04
-1.55%
DVN
35.78
+0.43
+1.22%
NOV
35.54
+0.34
+0.97%
CLR
37.82
+0.16
+0.42%
CVE
10.28
+0.18
+1.78%
TSO
99.53
+1.66
+1.70%
PBA
34.13
-0.43
-1.25%
EQT
64.26
+0.42
+0.66%
PAA
21.58
-0.14
-0.64%
XEC
110.85
+1.48
+1.35%
COG
26.58
+0.17
+0.64%
BPL
55.8
-0.16
-0.29%
MPLX
34.19
+0.17
+0.50%
IEP
54.72
+0.54
+0.9967%
MRO
12.79
+0.06
+0.47%